top of page
Faded Shapes

Plotting vs. Pantsing

Finding Your Writing Process

In the world of writing, two primary approaches to crafting a narrative have emerged, often sparking lively debates among authors: plotting and pantsing. Plotting involves meticulously planning the story structure, character arcs, and major events before writing, whereas pantsing (flying by the seat of your pants) is a more spontaneous approach, allowing the story to unfold organically. This article delves into the merits and challenges of each method, offering insights to help writers discover their own path to story development.
Understanding Plotting
Plotting is akin to creating a roadmap for your narrative journey. It involves outlining the story, defining character trajectories, and establishing key plot points ahead of actual writing. This method provides a clear direction and can significantly streamline the writing process.
Advantages of Plotting:
  • Efficiency: With a detailed outline in place, writers can avoid major plot holes and redundancies, potentially reducing the need for extensive revisions.
  • Clarity: Knowing where the story is headed can clarify the purpose of each scene, ensuring that every element serves the overarching narrative.
  • Goal-Oriented: For writers with deadlines or those who thrive on structure, plotting offers a systematic approach to meeting writing goals.
Challenges of Plotting:
  • Rigidity: Strict adherence to an outline may stifle spontaneity, potentially limiting character development and the exploration of unexpected narrative paths.
  • Time-Consuming: The initial outlining process can be time-intensive, delaying the actual writing phase.
Embracing Pantsing
Pantsing celebrates creativity and spontaneity, allowing the story and characters to evolve naturally. Without a predefined outline, writers discover the plot as they write, which can lead to unexpected twists and turns.
Advantages of Pantsing:
  • Creativity: This approach can unleash creativity, encouraging writers to explore various narrative possibilities without the constraints of an outline.
  • Flexibility: Pantsing allows for greater flexibility in story development. If new ideas or characters emerge, they can be seamlessly integrated into the narrative.
  • Discovery: Many writers find joy in the process of discovery that comes with pantsing, experiencing the story unfolding alongside their characters.
Challenges of Pantsing:
  • Revisions: Without a predetermined structure, pantsed manuscripts may require more extensive revisions to ensure coherence and narrative flow.
  • Uncertainty: The lack of a clear direction can be daunting for some writers, potentially leading to writer’s block or unfinished manuscripts.
Finding Your Writing Process
The debate between plotting and pantsing is not about prescribing a one-size-fits-all approach but understanding that each writer’s process is unique. Here’s how you can find your own path:
  • Experiment: Try both methods to see which resonates with your writing style. You may discover that a hybrid approach, combining elements of plotting and pantsing, works best for you.
  • Know Your Story’s Needs: Some stories may benefit from the structure plotting provides, while others may thrive on the spontaneity of pantsing. Consider what your narrative requires to reach its full potential.
  • Listen to Your Characters: Often, characters will guide the story. Whether you begin with an outline or not, remain open to following your characters’ lead.
  • Embrace Flexibility: Be willing to deviate from your initial plan (or lack thereof). Writing is an iterative process, and flexibility can lead to richer, more nuanced narratives.
Plotting vs. Pantsing: A Spectrum
It’s essential to recognize plotting and pantsing as points on a spectrum rather than dichotomous categories. Many successful authors fall somewhere in between, employing techniques from both approaches to suit their creative needs.
  • Plotting with Room for Spontaneity: Some plotters leave gaps in their outlines to allow for creative exploration during the writing process.
  • Pantsing with Milestones: Pantsers may not outline extensively but might establish a few key milestones to aim for, providing a loose framework for their narrative.
Emphasizing Process Over Prescription
Ultimately, the choice between plotting and pantsing is deeply personal, reflecting an author’s creative philosophy, workflow preferences, and the demands of the specific project at hand. The goal is not to rigidly adhere to one method but to develop a writing process that fosters creativity, productivity, and personal satisfaction.
Plotting and pantsing represent two approaches to storytelling, each with its own set of benefits and challenges. As writers navigate their creative journeys, understanding and experimenting with these methods can unlock new levels of narrative depth and efficiency. Whether through meticulous outlines or the thrill of discovery, the path to a compelling story is as diverse as the writers who tread it. Finding your writing process is an ongoing adventure—one that evolves with every story you tell.

Keywords: Writing process, plotting, pantsing, story development, writer's method.
bottom of page